Prior to moving into the
Fairview Church, the assembly had an evangelistic campaign. The speaker
was a Canadian missionary named Fred Clark. Marvellous things happened.
Remarkable healings occurred in answer to prayer. Although Fred Clark
was the speaker, he was at pains to declare that it was Fred Mullan’s
ministry in prayer, not his own, that brought about these healings.
Indeed, in the years that I knew Fred Mullan, I came to look on him as
having a vibrant evangelistic ministry and a clear gift of healing.
One remarkable healing concerned a young boy who had been crippled by polio.
When God restored his legs perfectly, about 12 members of his wider family
circle were saved and became staunch members of the church.
~
The Fairview Assembly grew under Fred Mullan’s ministry. It became
the centre for wider gatherings. Every Easter the Fairview Assembly hosted
a convention which was attended by Christians from far and wide. The entire
missionary body of the Assemblies of God would attend, some from as far
afield as the Eastern Transvaal and Mozambique. Speakers were selected
from those attending. The ministry was rich, the worship spontaneous and
anointed. It generated in me a lasting hunger for reality in spiritual
matters and a discontentment with the shallow manifestations that often
pass for Pentecostal worship nowadays.
Fred Mullan himself grew in personal influence in the Johannesburg scene.
He was well-known and widely respected. When famous evangelists like Oral
Roberts, William Branham and Betty Baxter came to South Africa, he was
always on the organising committee and played a prominent role in arranging
meetings for them. One could say that he was not only a pillar in the Assemblies
of God, but in the wider Pentecostal church as well.
~
I consider it a tragedy for the Assemblies of God that the two Mullan brothers
were not able to co-operate more actively in leading the Assemblies in
the pioneering days. Had they done so, the result would have been a well-nigh
invincible stability in the overall work. Divisions which resulted in later
splits might have been avoided.
As it was however, Fred and Jim differed radically on a number of doctrinal
points as well as on their respective philosophies of church planting and
church government. The General Executive made it a practice to downplay
disputes which could be viewed as differences of opinion open to varied
interpretations; matters like the long-standing contention on “eternal
security”. In this respect, Fred might have ranked as a Calvinist;
Jim as more of an Arminian. In other words, Fred taught that one, once
saved was always saved, even if one backslid. Jim taught that a believer
could apostasise and go to hell as a backslider.
Fred was amillennial in his teaching on eschatology. In other words, he
did not expect a thousand of years of peace before the final act of Christ’s
coming. Jim Mullan expected a thousand years of peace on earth. But both
brothers believed unwaveringly that Jesus would come in physical presence.
What a pity that they did not leave it at that and agree to differ. Many
people felt it was foolish to get heated over an academic question that
would only be resolved once the Day came.
Of a more down to earth significance was their dispute over church planting,
or the way to found new churches.
Jim Mullan was driven by the view that he was called to start assemblies
far and wide wherever there was the slightest possibility of planting a
church. He looked after the new congregations by organising a team of co-workers
to minister to them and to itinerate amongst them, staying for about two
years in any one assembly.
Fred, on the other hand, favoured the model so successfully exemplified
in Sweden by the great Lewi Pethrus, founder of the Pentecostal Churches
in Sweden. Pethrus built up a mega-church of six thousand in Stockholm,
a huge congregation for those days. He did not favour a proliferation of
smaller churches in any one city.
Fred Mullan wanted the Fairview Assembly to be a similar mother church
in Johannesburg, with any other churches revolving about Fairview as part
of the same system.
His vision made him defensive of the whole territory on the Rand. Far from
welcoming any effort to pioneer new congregations on the Rand, he opposed
such activities as an intrusion. Not surprisingly, fierce contentions resulted
in several places.
Probably Fred Mullan failed to grasp that his position and that of Lewi
Pethrus were very different. When Pethrus started in Sweden in 1910 there
were no other competing Pentecostal churches there. Thirty years later
in Johannesburg Fred Mullan had many competing elements to cope with. Even
in the Assemblies of God, there were a number of heterogeneous groups forming.
Lewi Pethrus was a powerful leader who started clean before other groups
were able to form. Fred Mullan came later into a dynamic and heterogeneous
situation. He lacked the ability to regulate developments as he wished
to do.
The differences between the Mullan brothers spilt over into the Assemblies
that inevitably formed around them as dynamic leaders. Bad blood resulted.
As the years passed and the Assemblies of God grew, overseas missionaries,
(particularly those from America) lent their voices to the contention.
Nicholas Bhengu and his black assemblies also became targeted. Fred Mullan’s
sympathies were with the missionaries and against his brother.
But let this be said: Whatever his sympathies were, Fred Mullan was always
godly in his dealings. He never used his position as General Chairman of
the Assemblies of God in any unfair way to the detriment of Jim Mullan
and his group of assemblies. The same can be said of his dealings with
Nicholas Bhengu’s black work.
It is a pity and more than a pity that these outstanding blood brothers
were not able to accommodate to each others’ foibles and even to
their weaknesses and to work more closely together.
With hindsight one has to say that in the main part, the assemblies led
by Jim Mullan and his successors prospered in spite of all opposition.
The later history of the Fairview connection is sadly different.
|